Stanley Cup: My picks for the Eastern Playoffs
Updated July 9, 2026
The 2026 Eastern Conference bracket is a beautiful, chaotic mess. We have legendary cores looking for one last sunset, young superstars finally getting their "Welcome to the Show" moment, and a few massive question marks hanging over the perennial favorites.
Here is why this year's first round is going to be an absolute gauntlet.
The Story: Experience vs. Chaos.
This series shouldn't even be happening. The Penguins had a disastrous post-Olympic stretch; with both Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin sidelined, many thought the wheels had finally fallen off the wagon. Instead, they gutted out enough points to stay alive. Now, with their veteran core healthy, this isn't just a playoff series – it’s a quest for one more Cup before the window slams shut. It is exciting to see Crosby, Malkin, Kris Letang, Bryan Rust and Erik Karlsson have another go at the cup.
However, the Flyers are a nightmare matchup for an aging Pittsburgh. Matvei Michkov has evolved into a terrifying offensive engine, but the real danger for Pittsburgh is the style of play. Philadelphia wants to turn this into a "muck and grind" marathon. While the Penguins rely on structured execution, a gritty, five-on-five war of attrition heavily favors the younger, nastier Flyers.
I believe the Battle for Pennsylvania is the dream matchup for Flyers – nothing to lose – and they can get under the Penguins' skin. Just look at the five-game suspension got Malkin during the Sabres game.
PIT/PHI Series winner odds: PIT -142 / PHI +118
The Story: Can youth overcome experience?
Montreal is back. Nick Suzuki just cemented his superstar status by hitting the 101-point mark, leading a Habs team that is finally ready to contend. Adding to that youth theme, they have Cole Caufield and D-man Lane Hutson, 25 and 22 years respectively, If we compare the two teams' average age, MTL is at 25.63 years whereas Tampa Bay sits at 29.43. Naturally, we need to mention Corey Perry's 40 years here. The hockey elder has been in 6 Stanley Cup Finals, but only won it once, which was with Ducks back in 2007. Do what you want with that information.
Tampa Bay Lightning is a strong contender for the cup, and Nikita Kucherov remains arguably the most dangerous playmaker in the world. There is a lot of star power in Tampa, and their goalie Andrei Vasilevsky is the biggest favorite to win the Vezina. Despite having captain Victor Hedman out for personal reasons this season, they've done very well, reaching 106 points and the 2nd place in the Atlantic (Canadiens also got 106 and ended up 3rd).
Of course we must note that this matchup is a rematch of the Stanley Cup Final back in 2021, where Tampa won it in five games. This season series have been even scores with two wins each, with the Habs winning the two last games.
Tampa Bay are the favorites to go through here, but they have lost the first round three years in a row. I think this could be another upset and Habs go through.
TBL/MTL Series winner odds: TBL -285 / MTL +230
The Story: Routine vs. Raw Power.
Buffalo is finally back in the dance, ending a 14-year drought that felt like a lifetime. Tage Thompson has been a human highlight reel this year, using his reach and 99th-percentile shot speed to overwhelm defenders. The Sabres play with a "nothing to lose" speed that can stretch any defense thin. The Sabres have been playing offensive hockey but the playoffs are something different. And I think Bruins could be a really bad matchup for Buffalo.
Buffalo's biggest hurdle is the lack of routine. The Boston Bruins have been here before – literally every year. They are the masters of structure and discipline. While Buffalo wants to track-race, Boston wants to squeeze. The Bruins' ability to slow the game down and rely on their veteran experience might be the cold water that douses the Sabres' fire. In the playoffs, when the whistles go away, Boston’s muscle memory usually wins out. Add to that, David Pastrnak had another season with +100 points, and Morgan Geekie is having a breakout season, not to mention Jeremy Swayman in net who could take the Bruins all the way.
BUF/BOS Series winner odds: BUF -172 / BOS +142
The Story: System vs. Star Power.
The Ottawa Senators are the "feel-good" story of the East, ending their own playoff drought with a roster that can score in bunches with the likes of Dylan Cozens, Tim Stützle and veteran Claude Giroux. Brady Tkachuk is exactly the player you want in a playoff run. The Senators are unpredictable, dangerous, and playing with a house-money mentality. However, they are running head-first into the most disciplined tactical system in hockey: the Carolina Hurricanes.
Rod Brind'Amour’s squad is a machine built on pressure and puck control. Unlike the Senators, the Hurricanes have been here before, year after year, refining their "suffocation" style. Ottawa has the flashes of brilliance to steal games, but they lack the playoff routine to sustain that intensity over seven games against a team that doesn't beat itself. If Ottawa can't break the system early, Carolina will simply wear them down. I think Ottawa could have a good run if it wasn't for this matchup. Carolina is just a powerhouse with names like Sebastian Aho, Andrei Svechnikov and Nikolaj Ehlers. But the thing with Hurricanes is, that they just dont rely on a few, they rely on many, so you have multiple lines that can grind any team down, including the Sens.
CAR/OTT Series winner odds: CAR -172 / OTT +142
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bFfZLlyaAH8
Get our 60-second breakdown of the first round in the Eastern Conference
Final Thoughts: The East is a toss-up. Between Pittsburgh's veteran heart, Montreal's rising stars, and the sheer unpredictability of Ottawa and Buffalo, there are no "easy" series this year. Buckle up.
Be sure to follow our NHL page with picks for the playoffs or go straight to the point and check out our Daily NHL Best Bets.
Affiliate DisclosureATS.io uses affiliate links. If you sign up through a link on this page, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Rankings are based on hands-on testing and published criteria, and affiliate relationships do not determine placement.
