Aston Villa vs Tottenham Prediction: Villa Deepen Spurs' Misery
Updated July 9, 2026
Aston Villa to win to nil (-140) is the pick. Our model prices it at -170, a 5.4% edge the market is leaving on the table because books are anchoring on Villa's inconsistent recent form rather than what happens when they face a Tottenham side missing eleven players and fighting relegation with a depleted squad.
Tottenham have failed to score in three of their last five away games. Their frontline without Solanke, Kulusevski, Simons and Maddison is Richarlison leading the line with Kolo Muani and Mathys Tel in support. Villa have kept clean sheets in three of their last five home fixtures. Fair Price: -170.
Premier League GW36
Aston Villa
-185
vs
Sun May 3
Tottenham
+500
Predicted score
2 - 0
Aston Villa win
Last 5 H2H (all comps)
W3 D1 L1
Villa record vs Spurs
Best bet
Aston Villa to win to nil
-140
~5.4% model edge • 4/5 confidence
Sharp take
The public is anchoring on Villa's inconsistent run and treating this like a competitive mid-table contest. The sharps are looking at the matchup: eleven Tottenham players unavailable, a front line missing every meaningful attacking threat, and Villa at home needing points for Champions League qualification. Villa to nil at -140 is the number the market is leaving on the table.
The market is pricing this game off Villa's recent wobble . A narrow loss at Fulham, and a draw before that. They are also treating it like Tottenham still have enough to threaten. They don't. Spurs have eleven players unavailable, including every meaningful creative outlet in their squad. Solanke is out. Kulusevski is out for months after surgery. Simons is done for the season with an ACL. Maddison remains absent. What's left is a relegation-threatened side running on Richarlison, Kolo Muani and a patchwork midfield against a Villa team that has beaten them twice already this season.
Villa's top scorers are Watkins and Rogers on eight goals apiece. Tottenham have failed to score in three of their last five away fixtures. The nil is the line. With Villa chasing Champions League qualification and Tottenham barely capable of threatening at full strength, the clean sheet here is as close to certainty as this market offers.
Villa sit fifth in the Premier League and are level on points with fourth. A win here keeps them firmly in the Champions League race. Emery's 4-2-3-1 is built around the Rogers-Watkins axis, with Rogers accumulating eight goals and five assists this season and showing the kind of consistent link play that will pull Tottenham's patchwork midfield out of shape. Watkins is also on eight league goals and will face a central defensive pairing of Danso and van de Ven that has been offering varying levels of reliability depending on Spurs' fitness situation on any given week.
Tielemans and Bogarde, covering for the injured Kamara and the doubtful Onana, form a midfield pivot that will have ample time on the ball against Bentancur and Bissouma. Villa have averaged 2.06 points per game at home this season, and that figure has been built on controlled possession, pressing in transition, and exploiting space with Maatsen's overlapping runs from the left. McGinn's energy on the right flank creates a different kind of problem for Udogie or Spence.
Tottenham's attacking threat is structurally broken at this point. Without Solanke, Kulusevski and Simons in the same squad, De Zerbi is asking Richarlison, Kolo Muani and Tel to generate enough to trouble a Villa defence that has conceded just once in their last three home league outings.
Kolo Muani's performances have been underwhelming by the Italian's own admission and Tel, operating as a wide player rather than a central striker, hasn't shown the consistency away from home to cause problems against a settled backline. Bentancur and Bissouma in midfield are reliable defensively but won't unlock Villa's block.
The previous two meetings between these sides this season both ended 2-1 to Villa. Tottenham have failed to win in 16 of their last 17 Premier League matches. Villa have won three of the last five h2h meetings across all competitions.
Boubacar Kamara is confirmed out with injury, removing Villa's most combative midfield presence. Lamare Bogarde steps into the pivot alongside Tielemans, which is a significant step down in defensive physicality but shouldn't be tested too heavily against this Spurs attack. Amadou Onana is also a doubt after being left out of the matchday squad against Fulham with a minor complaint. Emery confirmed it was a "small pain" and he didn't want to risk him — with Onana out of the equation, the midfield structure shifts toward Tielemans as the primary ball-carrier. Alysson Edward, Villa's backup forward, is also absent.
Emiliano Martinez is fit and starts in goal. The back four of Cash, Konsa, Mings and Maatsen is settled and experienced enough to handle a Tottenham attack of this profile. Jacob Ramsey is suspended after his red card against Bournemouth, which is why Barkley slots into the number ten role. Rogers and McGinn provide the wide threat, and Watkins leads the line.
For Tottenham, the injury list is genuinely extraordinary. Confirmed absentees include Solanke (muscle), Simons (ACL, season over), Kulusevski (knee surgery, months out), Romero (suspended then injured), Maddison (knee), Kudus (thigh), Ben Davies (injury), and Odobert (injury). Destiny Udogie is a doubt after a muscle problem against Wolves, though De Zerbi expressed hope he'd be available at Villa Park. Pape Sarr has a shoulder issue and is unlikely to feature. Vicario's fitness has also been managed carefully throughout the season.
De Zerbi is working with a squad so thin that Kinsky continues in goal, Danso and van de Ven partner at centre-back, and the attacking options are exhausted before they even begin. This is not the Tottenham side that beat Villa 4-1 in November. It's a squad in crisis, managed by a coach whose job security is itself uncertain, playing their third game in a week with a Europa League semi-final against Nottingham Forest also in the calendar.
Aston Villa
4-2-3-1
ST
Watkins
LW
Rogers
AM
Barkley
RW
McGinn
DM
Bogarde
DM
Tielemans
LB
Maatsen
CB
Mings
CB
Konsa
RB
Cash
GK
Martinez
vs
Tottenham Hotspur
4-2-3-1
ST
Richarlison
LW
Tel
AM
Gallagher
RW
Kolo Muani
DM
Bentancur
DM
Bissouma
LB
Udogie
CB
Danso
CB
Van de Ven
RB
Porro
GK
Kinsky
Subject to currently available data and injury news. Will be updated ahead of kickoff. Udogie is a doubt. Spence would come in at left back if he doesn't make it. Onana is a fitness concern for Villa and could be replaced by Barkley or Tielemans shifting roles.
Odds comparison
Aston Villa vs Tottenham
Bet Market Fair price Edge
Villa win to nil
Best bet • 4/5
-140 -170 +5.4%
Villa ML
Context
-185 -220 +2.8%
Watkins anytime
Props play
+135 +110 +3.2%
Rogers anytime
Props play
+175 +145 +3.5%
Spurs Under 0.5 goals
Secondary play
+115 +100 +2.9%
BTTS
No value
-120 +130 --
The market is anchoring on Villa's recent inconsistency and leaving value on the nil. Tottenham have eleven players out, haven't won a league game outside of a relegation six-pointer in four months, and carry forward options that have been visibly short of ideas and confidence. Villa have beaten them twice this season and are playing for Champions League football. The matchup couldn't be clearer.
Villa to win to nil at -140 is the best bet on the board. The model prices it at -170, meaning the market is offering plus money on what should be a clear favourite in this outcome. The goals come from Watkins and Rogers, Spurs don't find a way through, and Villa take three points in a result that keeps them in the Champions League conversation.
Who is the favorite for Aston Villa vs Tottenham?
Aston Villa are heavy home favorites at around -185. Tottenham are out at +500 and the draw is approximately +340.
What is the best bet for Aston Villa vs Tottenham?
Aston Villa to win to nil (-140). Our model prices the outcome at -170, a 5.4% edge. Tottenham have eleven players unavailable, their available forwards have been largely ineffective in recent weeks, and Villa have beaten Spurs twice this season already.
How many players are Tottenham missing for this game?
Eleven confirmed or likely absentees, including Solanke, Simons (ACL, season over), Kulusevski (post-surgery), Romero, Maddison, Kudus, Ben Davies, Odobert, and Pape Sarr. Destiny Udogie is also a doubt with a muscle problem.
What is the best Aston Villa prop for this game?
Morgan Rogers anytime scorer at +175. He has eight Premier League goals and five assists this season and will have space to cut inside from the left against Udogie or Spence at left back. The +175 undervalues a player who has been one of Villa's most consistent attacking threats all campaign.
Why are Villa not bigger favorites given Tottenham's injury crisis?
Villa's own recent form has been patchy. A loss at Fulham and a draw before that, which has kept the market cautious. But the matchup context and the eleven-player absentee list for Spurs make this a far more lopsided contest than the moneyline suggests. The nil is where the real value sits.
Affiliate DisclosureATS.io uses affiliate links. If you sign up through a link on this page, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Rankings are based on hands-on testing and published criteria, and affiliate relationships do not determine placement.
